10.Monopoly
In the conventional
positivist-based methodology found in today's textbooks, the term
"monopoly" has been warped into any firm facing a falling demand
curve. Since all firms face a
falling demand curve, the word "monopoly" has been rendered
meaningless. The original concept
of monopoly meant an exclusive privilege granted by the state, or literally one
seller. Even the textbooks
acknowledge these as types or sources of monopoly.
Some pertinent
examples of monopoly, correctly understood, would include the postal monopoly
(it is illegal for anyone else to deliver first class mail for under $3.00 per
letter), most power companies and cable television companies (it is illegal for
anyone else to sell these services in their territory--much like the Mafia turf
concept!), taxis in many cities (it is illegal to run without an expensive
medallion which the state limits in quantity), and public schools (which force
property owners to pay for them regardless of patronage).
The irony of so many
reformers who agonize over alleged monopolies generated in the free market is
that they never complain of the hordes of government-created monopolies. See for example Ralph Nader's The
Monopoly Makers for a
confirmation of this point. One
can only conclude that what so upsets these people is not monopolies but
private property, businesses, and the free market. For surely the monopoly power the post office exercises on a
daily basis and for decades now is far, far greater than any monopoly power a
business may enjoy from voluntary consumer patronage. No market-earned business monopoly (in the sense of one
seller) can forcibly eliminate its competitors or forcibly require revenues
from its customers the way the Post Office and other government-granted
monopolies do as a matter of routine.
-
Armentano, D. T.
Antitrust and Monopoly: Anatomy of a Policy Failure,
(New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1982)
-
Branden, Nathaniel
"Common Fallacies about Capitalism" in Capitalism the Unknown Ideal edited by Ayn Rand,
(New York: New American Library, 1967) pp. 72 -77.
-
Brown, Susan, et. al.
The Incredible Bread Machine,
(San Diego, California: World Research Inc., 1974) pp. 66 - 79.
-
Brozen, Yale
Is Government the Source of Monopoly?,
(San Francisco: Cato Institute, 1979)
-
Burris, Alan
A Liberty Primer,
(Rochester, New York: Society for Individual Liberty, 1983) pp. 226 - 237.
-
Rothbard, Murray N.
Man, Economy, and State,
(Los Angeles: Nash Publishing, 1970) pp. 587 - 620.
|